[iblastoff]

i'd pick a header+ul element as well.

[pgo]

Originally Posted by iblastoff

i'd pick a header+ul element as well.

Me too.

Glad we got that sorted. Now we can move on to something important!

Just kidding. I perversely enjoy these little semantics games myself.

[herkalees]

Oh I've got plenty more...

[emil]

Don't think it's a heading. At least not in the form you've worded it.

Our specialities
Our company specializes in:

• item
• item
• item
• item

<Hn>
<p>
<ul>/<ol>

[wheedwacker]

Originally Posted by emil

Don't think it's a heading. At least not in the form you've worded it.

Our specialities
Our company specializes in:

• item
• item
• item
• item

<Hn>
<p>
<ul>/<ol>

why the content in the <p> tags? isn't that redundant?

[emil]

Sorry, I'm not sure I follow. Why would it be redundant?

<hn>Title</hn>
<p>Company bah blah</p>
<ul>list</ul>

I was too lazy to put end tags...


To me the way he worded his sentence "sounds" like a phrase and not like a heading. I might be wrong though.

[herkalees]

To me, the original way I presented it seemed more as a title <hn> that introduced a section containing a <ul>. If said title was a bit more lengthy, then it could be better represented by a <p>, since it would then be more of a paragraph than a title.

The way I intend to use it, though, is definitely more Title/UL based.

I can see the redundancy in the above example as well, but only when shown exactly like this:

Our specialities
Our company specializes in:

If, however, the second bit was more lengthy and not as similar as the first bit, the redundancy disappears.

[wheedwacker]

yeah, thats what i meant, herkalees. if the second part in the p tag was longer, it wouldn't be redundant, but for your original post, i thought just Our Specialities would be enough.

[freelancr]

<h2-6>Title</h2-6>
<ul>
<li>Blah</li>
<li>Blah</li>
<li>Blah</li>
<li>Blah</li>
</ul>

[freelancr]

regarding the dash thing, kinda pointless considering there isn't a key for anything other than a hyphen or underscore on a standard keyboard, so wouldn't be much up for discussion for CMS builders.

[Larixk]

Originally Posted by freelancr

<h2-6>Title</h2-6>
<ul>
<li>Blah</li>
<li>Blah</li>
<li>Blah</li>
<li>Blah</li>
</ul>

yup, that's what i would use.

altough four times "Blah" should hardly be considered to be listural data.

[herkalees]

Originally Posted by freelancr

regarding the dash thing, kinda pointless considering there isn't a key for anything other than a hyphen or underscore on a standard keyboard, so wouldn't be much up for discussion for CMS builders.

Yeah, I see where you're coming from with regard to clients using a CMS and typing in content via a text box. For everyone else who writes markup and content by hand, it's a topic that interests me quite a bit.